Tuesday, November 13, 2012

The Latin Phrase Semper Reformanda means “Always Reforming.”  The phrase speaks of the need for the Church to continually re-examine itself and its practices in light of scripture.  I have adopted this phrase as the name of my Blog, since I view it as not only important in the life of the Church, but also in my personal life and spiritual journey.

The phrase first appeared in a 1674 devotional by Jodocus van Lodenstein, who was an important figure in Dutch Reformed pietism#. Von Lodenstein recognized that the massive tectonic shift caused by the Protestant Reformation was not enough, and that reform is not a one time event, but should be an ongoing process. As the whole phrase states, in its original context:  “The church is reformed and always [in need of] being reformed according to the Word of God.” 





The church has been in a continuous state of evolution throughout its history; it has cycled through periods of recalcitrance and renewal, periods of persecution, titanic upheavals such as the Protestant Reformation, and centuries of being in a place of power and influence. In the West, it has fractured into countless sub-groups, and in the United States has become intertwined with the culture to such a degree that to many being an American or even a member of a certain political party is synonymous with being a Christian.

Thus, throughout its history, there has been a pattern of continual reformation to keep it on center and on mission; there is an ongoing struggle to maintain the right balance between Orthodoxy (right belief) and Orthopraxy (right practice.) Much like tectonic plates in the earth, shifting in the wrong direction creates pressure that will eventually give way and cause seismic activity of varying degrees that will ripple throughout the church. When the church has shifted -and in some cases careened wildly- off course, pressure is created by deviating from God’s intent that will eventually and inevitably release and cause a course correction.

In the first few centuries of the church, there were waves of persecution of varying length and intensity; being elevated to a position of leadership or prominence was often an open invitation for persecution or martyrdom. But in 312 AD, the Roman Emperor Constantine converted to Christianity and in an almost overnight change the church went from being persecuted to becoming the religion of the state. Over the centuries, a toxic brew of  power and wealth, an intermingled church and government combined with an unhealthy separation between clergy and laity, which was amplified by among many other factors, the average Christian not being able to read the Word of God for himself, brought about a millennium of corruption. After centuries of abuse of power by the church, an environment was created that caused more and more pressure on the tectonic plates of the church. Since the pressure was allowed to build for over a millennium, when the plates finally did give way, the resultant quake was massive. We can still feel the concussions rippling through the annals of history, sparked by the hammer blows of an unimportant monk in the insignificant town of Wittenberg, as Martin Luther nailed his 95 Thesis to the door of the town chapel, triggering the release of the enormous pressure and signaling the onset of the Protestant Reformation.

The Protestant Reformation returned us to the understanding that our relationship with God is not based on works, but is by faith alone. But we must not forget that the error in understanding that developed did not happen overnight; it was a slow drift over many years. One small incremental change after one small incremental change, over time amplified into such a monstrous distortion that resembled nothing of the biblical truth.

I recently watched a film that documents the building of the Gateway Arch in St. Louis. Architects and engineers had to take extreme care in the building of the foundation of each leg to insure they fell into extremely precise parameters. A deviation of more than 1/64th of an inch at the bottom could translate into several feet of error at the top, and the two legs of the arch would not be brought into alignment.

Such is the case with the church. We must heed the warning of the writer of Hebrews:

Therefore we must pay much closer attention to what we have heard, lest we drift away from it. (Hebrews 2:1 ESV)

The subtle deception of being part of error, is that while in the midst of it, it is extremely difficult to see how far off course we have drifted. Once the correction is made, however, we can look back with the proverbial 20/20 hindsight and see clearly the extent and ramifications of the error. For example, those of us on this side of history in Protestantism can look in horror at the Catholic system of penance that by the time of the Protestant Reformation had developed into the ability of people to essentially pay for the sins of themselves or even those who were deceased. It seems so obvious to us that this is a gross deviation from the Biblical truth of Christ's atoning for ALL of the sins of those who are in Him. But few are aware of the genesis of this system and how an extremely small deviation can amplify over centuries into grotesque error.

For much of the first three centuries, persecution was the norm for the church. In 249 AD however, the church was in a period in which persecution had relaxed and was rare for nearly a half a century- then the Roman emperor Decius took the throne. Where in previous persecutions, it was often the desire to eliminate christians, Decius saw that martyrdom had served to spread and strengthen the church; his plan was not to produce martyrs, but apostates. When Christians were arrested, the authorities tried to get them to recant their faith through a system of threats, intimidation and torture.

As can be expected, many did recant their faith, while others stood fast and refused to recant in the face of persecution. This period of persecution under Decius was brief, and In the wake of this persecution, those who stood firm in their faith were now highly respected in the church and became known as the “Confessors.” However, there were also many who did not, for one reason or another, stand firm in their faith. Some lapsed briefly under torture, others completely recanted, others fled into hiding; these became known as the “lapsed.” Some of the lapsed were remorseful and wanted to be reintroduced into the fellowship of the church. The question  arose of how to reintroduce those who desired it, back into fellowship. Some, including many of the Confessors, were advocating leniency in allowing the lapsed to be reintroduced; others felt that there needed to be more stringent requirements, and that there needed to be some proof and additional evidence to show their sincerity. It was in this environment that, in one form or another, requirements slowly began to be added to simple repentance. It was out of this struggle of how to reintroduce the lapsed coupled with a desire to maintain the purity of the church that the entire penitential system developed.#

It is not difficult to look at the distorted system that eventually developed and discern the error; but if we put ourselves in the place of these early Christians and ask ourselves what it would be like if we were in their place, it becomes a very different scenario, and the lines between truth and error are not as clearly defined. Would we be able to withstand under torture? How would we view those who did not, and would we require of them some other proof of their genuine faith? Could they be leaders in the church? How could you not view the Confessors with higher regard and respect? We know that our righteousness is in Christ alone, and not in what we do, no matter how great - even withstanding persecution. This ensures that even one of the “lapsed” who had wilted under duress and who later had truly repented of their failure would have the same standing before the Lord as one who had refused to recant even under the most cruel torture. This- out of no doubt the most honorable intentions of maintaining the purity of the church- created an environment that allowed one small deviation from the center of Biblical truth, one after another, again and again, over time compounding into extreme error.

It is very tempting to believe that at our point in history, we now have arrived at the end of the road in the search for knowledge and truth; that those who have gone before us were perhaps working with less than all of the tools and resources that we now have at our disposal, and we are now able to look at things with perfect objectivity and accurately assess our current state. However, in doing this, we can be guilty of what C.S. Lewis called “Chronological Snobbery”, or what Historian Timothy F. George calls “Imperialism of the Present.” If we are too narrowly focused at our point in history, truth can become distorted, and we can develop dogmatic belief that when examined against the backdrop of the word of God and history are stark deviations.

In the western church, we live in a very unique historical and cultural context. In America, for example, we have a culture where freedom, equality, consumerism, materialism, and rugged individuality are held among our highest virtues. This has infiltrated the church to such a degree that Christ has become only an accoutrement to our life, and is only allowed to be a part of it so long has he does not interfere with our pursuit of the American Dream. Christ’s demand for us to die to self and forsake all is completely foreign to much of American Christianity. We think nothing of the criterion for choosing where to go to church being which one offers us the most: do we like the pastor, and does his messages minister to us; does the childrens program meets our needs; do we like the style of worship; are there enough or the right kind of kids in the youth group for our children to be friends with. In essence, what does this church provide for me and my felt needs.
Almost no consideration is given to where we may be called to be a part of the body of Christ and to be a part of the mission to spread the Gospel. How many people actually seek God's purpose in their lives first, rather than Christ being an afterthought that we fit around our careers and other pursuits? How many people will go wherever God calls them and can stick with a fellowship through the painful times of growth or times when the church doesn’t function like a well oiled megachurch?

In much of Evangelical and especially in Fundamentalist America, being aligned with the Republican party is an unspoken requirement. Legitimate issues of life and morality have  inextricably intermingled politics and faith. Yet Jesus chose disciples who were on polar opposite ends of the political spectrum of His day. Simon was a Zealot, a member of the radical Jewish sect that militantly opposed the Roman Domination of Palestine, and Matthew was a tax collector for Rome. In many ways, the differences between the two was far greater than the difference between the average Democrat and Republican of today.

How many of us take notice that denominations do not exist in Scripture?  Every time a church is mentioned or referenced, it is the church in a particular city. Yet denominations are so prevalent in the western church that few of us give it a second thought. Is it possible that the fragmented church we see today, and do not give much thought to, is not really God’s perfect design for his Body? Do we really think that Christ’s body should be divided into rival factions?
These, and many other examples indicate that we have drifted from God’s design, and perhaps we have drifted farther than any of us would dare think. What the vast majority of Christians in the American church believe to be the norm throughout history is in fact an aberration from the early church and the church we see in the book of Acts.

How can we avoid the slow drift away from God’s purposes in the future? What can remove the fog of our environment and time in history from our interpretational lense to allow truth to be seen most clearly? Of course the obvious answer is God’s Word, and that would be the correct answer; but that would have also been the answer given to the very same question at many points in the history of the church when it was in, or in danger of being in, very serious error. The real question is then: how can we trust that our interpretation of Gods word is not clouded? For every person who believes that God’s word is the final authority believes that they are interpreting it correctly.

As always, we should be relentlessly Biblically centered. We must be Berean and “examine the scripture daily.” The Bible is the standard of truth and the measuring rod against which all things must be tested.

We must “test EVERYTHING; hold fast what is good.” 1 Thess 5:21

Testing all things against Scripture, combined with guidance from the Holy Spirit that is sought through prayer is the primary answer to avoiding the slow drift.

And your ears shall hear a word behind you, saying, “This is the way, walk in it,” when you turn to the right or when you turn to the left.
(Isaiah 30:21)

Additionally, I believe that there is a principle -in fact an imperative- in Scripture that is too often tragically ignored. Hebrews 11 -the hall of faith chapter- along with Hebrews 13:7 provide powerful incentive to study and learn from those who have gone before us:

Remember your leaders, those who spoke to you the word of God. Consider the outcome of their way of life, and imitate their faith.” (Hebrews 13:7).

One might be tempted to object that these instructions are restricted to those specific examples in Scripture, or only our immediate leaders, and it would be difficult to make a case otherwise if these were the only passages that speak on this matter. Philippians 3:17 extends the sphere beyond these restrictions:

Brothers, join in imitating me, and keep your eyes on those who walk according to the example you have in us. (Philippians 3:17)

I see no reason why this should not include those in the past who have walked according to this example; and what better way to examine and study the validity of their faith but by reading and learning about those who have stood firm in the faith while living in circumstances and times in history that is different than ours?

In science, the more measurements and tests that are performed increases accuracy. For example, if a person wanted to make an estimate of the average depth of the ocean, the accuracy of the estimate would increase with more and more measurements and locations. If only one measurement were made, the answer could vary from between 6 miles and 3 feet. if 10 measurements were made, the answers could vary from 200’ to 6000’, and if thousands of measurements were made at various locations, the most accurate estimation of 12400’ would be the answer.

Likewise, when we study the lives of those who have gone before us, we are examining how the truths of Scripture have stood the test of time and circumstance. The more we see how they have lived out their faith in various circumstances and historical contexts, the more clearly the Biblical truth can be seen. The truth of Scripture is like gold, unchanging and fundamental so that it cannot be broken down into any other parts. Studying church history is like digging for gold. By brushing off the dirt and grime that can accumulate over time, the gold can be seen all the more brightly.

The health and wealth movement has no place in the early church and the lives of the apostles;  it does not flourish under persecution, yet it has found a home in materialistic America, and in impoverished areas with little biblical knowledge and influence.
A quick glance at the broad picture of the church both in the world, and over its history would expose the health and wealth doctrine for the aberration that it is.

Perhaps in a conscious effort to address this need to have historical validity, the Emergent Church movement has attempted to tie universalism to the early church. By using what can only be described as overt deception, Rob Bell and those of his ilk have attempted to rewrite church history by showing their beliefs have historical gravitas, yet even the most surface level investigation into the history of the church would show that it has none. A couple generations of a biblically weak, self centered, materialistic American church has created a new generation that has become disgusted with the church’s hypocrisy; and since they have not been grounded biblically, they are the perfect breeding ground for this heresy to prosper.
Just as any other false movement that has severed the chain to the anchor of the Bible, the Emergent Church will fade into history; how far off course they will drift in the sea and how much damage they will do before there is a correction, only history will be able to tell. But that there will inevitably be a correction, there can be no doubt.
Of course, an examination against Scripture first should show the error, but if it can’t be seen for the cultural fog, examining it against history would show that it is merely grime destined to be scrubbed off of the gold.

If the followers of Harold Camping, or others who have attempted to predict the second coming of Christ or tried to tie current events to Biblical prophecy would do a little investigation into church history, they would discover that while the Bible is always 100% accurate in its prophecies, the success rate of people attempting to accurately predict both the their timing and nature before they take place is at or very near 0%. Every detail of the life of Christ was accurately predicted in the Old Testament, from the place of his birth to the details of his crucifixion hundreds of years before he was born; yet how many of his disciples could see them before hand?

There is a vein of thought that we can often find in the western church, that usually goes something like this: “We don’t need to study history or doctrine, we just need the Bible,” or “We just need Jesus.” The problem with this line of thought, is that, 1. it is un-biblical, and 2. it arrogantly assumes that their perspective is neutral.

Only by relentless, unswerving dedication to the word of God can we avoid drifting off course, and this would include the mandate of Philippians 3:17 of keeping our eyes on those who have walked according to the example of the apostles, both now and those who have gone before us. We and the church must be “Always Reforming.”  

No comments:

Post a Comment