In a quest to find out what I believe about the Biblical Doctrine of Hell, I have recently read 5 books on the topic from various perspectives and am currently reading 5 more. One of the books I have read, Hope Beyond Hell is from the Christian Universalist perspective or alternatively Postmortem Salvationism; I would like to discuss this book in particular in this note.
Since I don’t have access to the author himself, I have some thoughts about the book that I did not feel were fully addressed and some questions that were either not addressed at all, or were not addressed to my satisfaction. I am opening this up for discussion, for anyone would like to participate in this very important topic, and am open to be challenged and have my perspective questioned. This -I believe- is the healthiest environment for discovery of truth.
I can’t address every single point in the book, but below -I believe- are some of the topics that are of utmost importance in no particular order, followed by my summary review.
1. Church History
A major premise of the book is that the doctrine of eternal punishment originated with Augustine, and that those opposing it were in the the minority and he gives several quotes from early church leaders in Appendix IV.I am not able to substantiate this claim; in fact the evidence seems to be quite the contrary. Most amazingly to me, many of the quotes I have found are by the very people he quotes in the appendix as evidence that the early church did not believe in eternal punishment. Below are a few quotes from many of the most influential early church fathers that I have found while trying to substantiate his claim; this list represents about 20% of all the ones I have available. I have put in bold people those from whom he has already quoted:
“.. For they kept before their view escape from that fire which is eternal and will never be quenched” Martyrdom of Polycarp (AD 135)
“..Those who have known God and have seen His mighty works, but still continue in evil, will be chastised doubly, and will die forever.” Hermas (AD 150)
“Christ foretold that Satan would be sent into the fire with his host, along with the men who follow him, and they will be punished for an endless duration.” Justin Martyr (AD160)
“Some are sent to be punished unceasingly into judgement and condemnation of fire” Justin Martyr (AD160)
“We know from Isaiah that the members of those who transgressed will be consumed by the worm and unquenchable fire, remaining immortal” Justin Martyr (AD160)
“We who are now easily susceptible to death, will afterwards receive immortality with either enjoyment or with pain” Tatian (AD 160)
“Therefore , burning fire will come upon you, and you will daily burn in flames forever.”Theophilus (AD 180)
“thus also the punishment of those who do not believe the Word of God, and despise His advent, and are turned away backwards, is increased; being not merely temporal, but rendered also eternal.” Irenaeus- (AD 180)
“ Now good things are eternal and without end with God, and therefore the loss of these things is also eternal and never ending. “ Irenaeus (AD 180)
“Eternal Fire is prepared for sinners. The Lord has plainly declared this, and the rest of scripture demonstrates it.” -Irenaeus (AD 180)
“ All souls are immortal, even those of the wicked. Yet, it would be better for them if they were not deathless. For they are punished with an endless vengeance of quenchless fire, since they do not die, it is impossible for them to have an end put to their misery.” Clement of Alexandria (AD 195)
“...the magnitude of the threatened torment. For it is not merely long-enduring; rather, it is everlasting.” Tertullian (AD 197)
“We, however, so understand the soul’s immortality as to believe it to be “lost” - not in the sense of destruction- but of punishment” Tertullian (AD 197)
“ There is neither limit nor termination of these torments.” Mark Minucius Felix (AD 200)
The latest of these quotes is nearly 200 years before the birth of Augustine, so it is clear that he could not have been the primary originator of the doctrine of eternal punishment.This is troubling to me because this was not difficult information to find. The only two ways I can think of that would account for their absence from being quoted, is deception or sloppy research; neither of these is a very good way to build trust with the reader-particularly this one. Regardless, the book is not presenting an accurate picture of the beliefs of the early church.
2. The Unpardonable Sin
In Appendix V, the question of the unpardonable sin is addressed. He uses Mark 3:29-30 as the passage to discuss, and uses the Young’s Literal Translation as one of the versions to show that the punishment for the unpardonable sin is not eternal.
but whoever may speak evil in regard to the Holy Spirit hath not forgiveness -- to the age, but is in danger of age-enduring judgment;' MARK 3:29YLT
Leaving aside the accuracy of the translation for the moment, the inescapable conclusion of this perspective is that there are people who are going to be punished for sins for which Christ did not suffer punishment; and there is a group of people who apparently are able to get into heaven outside of the atonement, or at least some aspects of it.
Secondly, the other passage that addresses the unpardonable sin (Matt 12:32) is mysteriously left out of the response. For the sake of this discussion I will use the YLT, since that is apparently the accepted translation.
And whoever may speak a word against the Son of Man it shall be forgiven to him, but whoever may speak against the Holy Spirit, it shall not be forgiven him, neither in this age, nor in that which is coming. Matt 12:32 YLT
Since there is only this age and the “one which is coming” :When is this sin ultimately forgiven? Is it not necessary for this sin to be forgiven to be allowed entrance into heaven? Or is there another option I am not thinking of?
Thirdly, the universal extent of the atonement is asserted using verses like:
he is a propitiation for our sins, and not for ours only, but also for the whole world, 1 John 2:2 YLT
While I am in agreement with the recognition that propitiation truly does mean an actual and final removal of sin, and not just a potential one, I’m confused how sins that have been paid for actually, completely and finally for everyone are being punished again on these people, when they should have already been laid on Christ?
He admits as much in Appendix V:“It is comforting to know that our loving Father is committed to consume all evil in us.”This is a breathtaking statement. The Atonement was not complete?How does this doctrine not undermine and redefine the atonement?
3. The Marriage Supper of the Lamb and the Book of Life
The Bride of Christ is presented to the bridegroom in Revelation 19:6 as a chaste virgin who has been sanctified and no spot or wrinkle Eph 5:25-26.
Eternal life is not the only thing purchased by Christ on the cross, also sanctification.
And by that will we have been sanctified through the offering of the body of Jesus Christ once for all.(Hebrews 10:10)
For by a single offering he has perfected for all time those who are being sanctified.
(Hebrews 10:14)
We know that our old self was crucified with him in order that the body of sin might be brought to nothing, so that we would no longer be enslaved to sin.(Romans 6:6)
- Why are those who will suffer in hell not sanctified in this life?
- Is there another marriage supper for those who are in Hell AFTER the first Marriage Supper?
Only Those whose names are written in the Lamb's book of life are allowed to enter into heaven.Rev 20:15 and Rev 21:17.
- When will those in hell’s names be written in the book of life?
- Why does it say ONLY those written in the book of life get to go into heaven if it would require ALL names to be written in the book of life to accept universal redemption?
4. Unaddressed and Miscellaneous verses/ topics
This list is far from complete, but these are some of the highlights.There are several verses that support the finality of death, the importance of belief in this life, and do not support redemptive punishment.
For in death there is no remembrance of you; in Sheol who will give you praise? -Psalm 6:5
Do you work wonders for the dead?Do the departed rise up to praise you? Selah
Is your steadfast love declared in the grave (Sheol),or your faithfulness in Abaddon?- Psalm 88:10
The dead do not praise the LORD, nor do any who go down into silence.- Psalm 115:17
But he who is joined with all the living has hope, for a living dog is better than a dead lion. 5For the living know that they will die, but the dead know nothing, and they have no more reward, for the memory of them is forgotten. 6Their love and their hate and their envy have already perished, and forever they have no more share in all that is done under the sun. Ecc 9:4-6
for her house sinks down to death,and her paths to the departed;none who go to her come back, nor do they regain the paths of life. Proverbs 2:18-19
and come out, those who have done good to the resurrection of life, and those who have done evil to the resurrection of judgment.
(John 5:29)
Whoever loves his life loses it, and whoever hates his life in this world will keep it for eternal life.
(John 12:25)
For many, of whom I have often told you and now tell you even with tears, walk as enemies of the cross of Christ. Their end is destruction, their god is their belly, and they glory in their shame, with minds set on earthly things.
(Philippians 3:18-19)
For it is impossible, in the case of those who have once been enlightened, who have tasted the heavenly gift, and have shared in the Holy Spirit, and have tasted the goodness of the word of God and the powers of the age to come, and then have fallen away, to restore them again to repentance, since they are crucifying once again the Son of God to their own harm and holding him up to contempt.
(Hebrews 6:4-6 ESV)
For if we go on sinning deliberately after receiving the knowledge of the truth, there no longer remains a sacrifice for sins, but a fearful expectation of judgment, and a fury of fire that will consume the adversaries. Anyone who has set aside the law of Moses dies without mercy on the evidence of two or three witnesses. How much worse punishment, do you think, will be deserved by the one who has trampled underfoot the Son of God, and has profaned the blood of the covenant by which he was sanctified, and has outraged the Spirit of grace? For we know him who said, “Vengeance is mine; I will repay.” And again, “The Lord will judge his people.” It is a fearful thing to fall into the hands of the living God.
(Hebrews 10:26-31 ESV)
- Matt 25 talks about the separation between the sheep and the goats. Who are the Goats? It would seem that the book would have us believe that All people are sheep. The shepherd lays down his life for the sheep, yet John 10:26 is clear that not all are sheep.
but you do not believe because you are not among my sheep.
My sheep hear my voice, and I know them, and they follow me. I give them eternal life, and they will never perish, and no one will snatch them out of my hand (John 10:26-28)
- The Bible says that it is the Kindness of God that leads us to repentance. How is it loving of God to torture people for what the book admits could be for thousands of years into loving Him?
- The book talks about the restoration of all things, yet scripture precludes this from including Satan and Demons. Considering that those in hell go to the same place as the Devil and his Angels, are the Angels restored contrary to the book of Hebrews teaching that the atonement was not for Angels?
- A relatively minor issue, -that I wouldn’t bring up if a whole section wasn’t dedicated to it,- but Calvinism is on the one hand attempted to be used to give weight to the teaching against free will, and on the other hand completely and utterly misrepresented; from the common misperception that Calvinists are followers of John Calvin, and subsequent -also common- historically inaccurate account of Calvin’s involvement in the execution of Michael Servetus, to the complete mangling of Calvinism's teachings. Being a Calvinist, I am not unaccustomed to having what I believe misrepresented and misunderstood, and I would be tempted to be offended by the books inaccuracies, were they not so -almost humorously- far off base. Yet this is yet another example of intellectual dishonesty.
5. Translation
I found the discussion on Aion interesting. Of course the discussion on this topic is could be very lengthy and complicated, so I’ll just hit a few highlights.
Using the same logic and methodology as is used in the book, one could look up the root word for Love (Agape) and conclude that God doesn’t love us, he really only liked us. Or in Philippians 1:25 that to progress in Joy and Faith really means to “Cut down” because the root word for Prokopke is Kopto which is to cut off or down.
Or using a modern day example: Someone could look up a something written about -Lets say -Elton John that states he is a nice gay man, and -looking up root words and alternate meanings -conclude that what was really meant was that he was a STUPID HAPPY man, since the root word for Nice means to be foolish or stupid, and an alternate meaning of Gay is happy.Or they could dig a little deeper and look up the root word for Gay (Gai) and conclude that he was an stupid FAST man.
I have consulted multiple language study books and it is nearly universally accepted that studying root meanings of words is almost never an accurate way to determine what the word actually meant when it was penned.
One could come up with some incredibly off the wall interpretations of some of the most foundational teachings and words simply by giving credence to the meanings of root words.
What is important is what the word commonly meant, and how it would be understood by the audience.
It would have to be assumed that the author and the reader both had a working understanding of the history of all the words in Koine Greek and that they understood the words to mean some earlier version of the word and not the common understanding of the word at the time it was written. This can’t even apply in modern English where we have access to dictionaries; are we to believe the average Greek speaker in the the first century had this level of understanding of language development, so they would know that AIONIOS really meant age, though they never heard it used that way?
This also applies to the meaning of Punishment (Kolasis) which he makes the case that really means pruning; yet this is only 1 of 4 possible meanings of the ROOT word, and again there are no examples of it meaning pruning anywhere else in scripture.
While it could be shown that Aion does SOMETIMES mean age, that is of no use in determining what AIONIOS means just because AIONIOS is derived from AION. The fact remains that there are no instances of AIONIOS in the Bible that do not mean one of the following:1) without beginning and end, that which always has been and always will be-As in relating to God.2) without beginning.-As in Rom 16:253) without end, never to cease, everlasting
At the end of the discussion all that is left, is that the word from which AIONIOS is derived SOMETIMES means age.
Even given this, when related to the afterlife, AION ALWAYS either refers to “This age” or “Age to come” There are simply no instances where the length of the afterlife is restricted in some sense. So all that is left is that it is THEORETICALLY possible for it to mean age when relating to the afterlife; there are just no examples of that to substantiate the claim.
In the discussion about the length of Aion being determined by the noun it is modifying, he quotes Habakuk 3:6 as a proof text stating that the septuagint translates both words as AIONION
“And the everlasting mountains were scattered.…His ways are everlasting” (Hab. 3:6).
Yet this is ABSOLUTELY FALSE. The Septuagint does NOT use the same word to translate both words as AIONION. It translates the Mountains as AIONION and His ways as AIONIOS
Again this is information that is readily available to anyone who takes the time to follow up and research these claims.
He makes the claim that “The adjective aionios... is used over one hundred times” in the septuagint, yet a quick electronic search through the septuagint reveals that it only occurs 13 times. These are just two more examples of false or misleading evidence that is presented in the book.
Moreover:It sounds like we are being asked to believe that God has allowed what would be well over 90% of Christians since the 4th century to believe a lie about himself because of one person (Augustine)He makes the (unsubstantiated) assertion that the translators of the major versions are believers in eternal punishment.
- How in the world would this be possible to verify, outside of having a personal biography of each person who has ever worked on a bible translation?The major translations were done by groups of several individuals, who has personal knowledge of the beliefs of the over 100 people from multiple denominational backgrounds who worked on the NIV for example.
- The YLT was translated by one person. What is more likely, that every person who has worked on a bible translation that says “eternal” in relation to hell has an agenda, or that one person who translated the bible has an agenda?
- Why is not believing in eternal punishment assumed to be the neutral position when translating the Bible, but you would be biased if you did believe in it?
- Are we seriously asked to believe that the vast majority of Christians throughout history have not had the correct bible translation? That the plain reading of scripture cannot be trusted? That the authors of scriptures such as Matt 25:46
(And these will go away into eternal punishment, but the righteous into eternal life.) -Which has evidently been mistranslated for 1600 years- If they didn’t mean both instances of eternal to mean the same thing, to not take the effort to make it more clear?
- How on the one hand can the author claim such a high view of God’s sovereignty, and on the other hand claim that God allowed this false view of his character to be perpetuated for so long?
6. The Doctrine of Eternal Punishment is not supported in The Old Testament.
I have spent a lot of time thinking about this, and I have to be honest in saying I am at a loss as to how this is a valid argument.Since when is a teaching being clear in the Old Testament the litmus test for truth? Isn’t that the whole point in now having the whole counsel of God? That things that were hidden, are now revealed?If we applied this to the doctrine of the trinity, the Deity of Christ, The plan of salvation to include Gentiles, we would have to reject those as well because they are certainly not clear in the Old Testament.Secondly, it seems extremely anachronistic to assume that this would not be clear to the Old Testament Jew, when everything in their life pointed to their separation from the holiness of God in the Temple. That being cut off from your people and your God and put outside the camp would have been the absolute worst thing that you could imagine. That a person with this mindset would have thought that those outside of God's covenant people would be united with Him after death, seems to me to be a massive stretch. It seems much more likely that it had to be more clearly taught in the New Testament to those who did not have all of this background.
7. God’s Desire/Does God get what God wants?
I’ve heard this argument on facebook, In Love Wins, and in this book. I’ll try to avoid getting into a whole discussion on particular redemption, but the whole premise is based on two verses. 1 TIm 2:4 and 2nd Peter 3:9
2nd Peter 3 is simply a matter of following context and the pronouns to determine the extent of the text. Unfortunately most people apply rules of Logic and grammar to this text that they would never dream of in any other circumstance in order to make is say what they think it should say, not what it actually says.
This is now the second letter that I am writing TO YOU, BELOVED (to whom it is addressed). In both of them I am stirring up your sincere mind by way of reminder,(2 Peter 3:1) The Lord is not slow to fulfill his promise as some count slowness, but is patient toward (Who is he patient toward? the whole world?no ) YOU , not wishing that any (Of whom, everyone in the world? no, the object of his patience -OF YOU) should perish, but that all (Of Whom? The whole world? All of YOU)should reach repentance. (2 Peter 3:9 )
For 1 Tim 2:4 First of all, then, I urge that supplications, prayers, intercessions, and thanksgivings be made for all people, (who? every single person on the face of the earth? No the answer follows in the text)for kings and all who are in high positions ( kinds and classes of people), that we may lead a peaceful and quiet life, godly and dignified in every way. This is good, and it is pleasing in the sight of God our Savior, who desires all people (Same wording as verse 1, it does not follow logically that we go from classes of people, to every single person in the space of a few sentences) to be saved and to come to the knowledge of the truth.(1 Timothy 2:1-4)
This is also the same wording that paul uses elsewhere, as in Titus 3:2:to speak evil of no one, to avoid quarreling, to be gentle, and to show perfect courtesy toward all people. (Titus 3:2 )
And in Paul's commissioning:'For you will be His witness to all men of what you have seen and heard. Acts 22:15
Do we really believe that he was a witness to every single person on the earth?
Again a much longer and different discussion, but the point is this is a major premise of the believe in universal redemption and it is a tenuous position at the very least for so much to hinge on the interpretation of only two verses.
8. Why I believe this is a dangerous belief.
I. It has to Redefine SalvationThis belief system would have that some are not saved from the wrath of God contrary to Rom 5:9, and some are subject to the penalty of sin.
Since, therefore, we have now been justified by his blood, much more shall we be saved by him from the wrath of God.(Romans 5:9)
Note that we are saved from the wrath of God. It is very confusing how on the one hand Christ took on the penalty of sin, and on the other hand some people are subject to the penalty of Sin which is Hell, yet hell isn’t really punishment, it is pruning. It is easy to see how the doctrine begins to fall apart when all of the corollary results are pursued. Every question that seems to be answered creates several more unanswered questions.
Salvation is always taught in scripture as three-fold
- Salvation from the penalty of Sin (Justification)
- Salvation from the power of Sin (Sanctification)
- Salvation from the presence of Sin (Glorification)
For those whom he foreknew he also predestined to be conformed to the image of his Son, in order that he might be the firstborn among many brothers. And those whom he predestined he also called, and those whom he called he also justified, and those whom he justified he also glorified.(Romans 8:29-30)
This is an unbreakable chain of redemption, and no one is exempt from the order. Yet apparently some are not justified and are subject to sin’s penalty.
II. It has to Redefine God’s Love as the primary emphasis in witnessing contrary to the example of Christ and the apostles. Paul described the fate of the wicked using words such as “Perish, destroy, wrath, punish” more than eighty times in his letters; that’s more than his reference to God’s forgiveness, mercy, or heaven combined!The message of Jesus and the Apostles is always repentance, not that God just loves everybody.
III. It must redefine God in terms of a human understanding of Love which then becomes His primary attribute; This is in opposition to Holiness being the most common and overarching description of His Being and CharacterGod is described as “Love” twice in the Bible, and “Holy” at least 33 times that I am able to find.
IV Fosters an attitude of complacency in witnessing that is not consistent with the Biblical theme of the importance of decisiveness in this life.Matt 12:32; 25:41, 46; 26:24; Luke 16:26; John 8 21; Rom 2:1-16; Rom 9:3; 2 Cor 5:10; Gal. 6:7.
V. In an effort to Air condition hell and defend God’s honor, a false Dichotomy is presented with the only options being God loving everyone equally, or a malicious sadistic God who enjoys torturing people.The end result is a worse picture is presented of God who has to twist people’s arms into loving him, than the true biblical teaching of hell as the quarantining of evil and the giving over of the wicked to their desire to be away from God’s presence, which comes with terrible ramifications.
VI. Old testament pictures of the passover and atonement being applied to God’s covenant have to be completely altered.Now the blood over the doorposts somehow has to be applied to Egypt as well.
VII As discussed before, the penalty of sin was not actually paid for by Christ, and there will be some people that will suffer the penalty of their sin.
The end result of the book, is that we are asked to believe that “eternal” means “temporary”, “punishment” means “pruning” ,“destruction” means “redemption,” “the worm that never dies” actually means the worm that eventually dies, “the fire that will never be quenched” really means the fire that will be quenched, and that easily over 90 percent of Christians throughout history have been believing a lie about God. All of these things of course have very complicated explanations given, but the end result is the same. In an anticipated response that the author would say we have to understand the eastern custom was to use the most vivid language possible. to which I respond: The bible was only written to those who are able to understand the eastern custom of writing, and not for all people?
This is by no means an attempt to address every single point in the book, rather it is an attempt to address some of the key issues that need brought up. If I were to attempt to address every example of faulty logic, every verse taken out of context, and every historical error, every false premise used to build an argument, this note would be twice as long as the book itself. At least this author -In contrast to the author of Love Wins -seeks to give answers and not just ask questions, is able to complete a thought and writes in complete sentences. Yet this book is dangerous because it masquerades in pseudo -scholarship and intellectualism.
In reading a little about this author, I have discovered that he does a lot of mission work and I believe is sincere in his effort to live a Christlike life, and for that he should be respected. Yet It is abundantly clear throughout the book that he has found the doctrine of hell problematic all of his life, and his motivations are transparent. What is tragic, is all of the effort that he has spent attempting to tear down a straw man
.My confidence remains strong that God is faithful to preserve his word and that it is written for the average person to be able to read and understand. It doesn’t take an expert in the Greek, to be able to understand its clear message.Though some of the truths may be difficult, at the end of the day, we must do as Job did when he was confronted with God’s absolute right to do as he pleases with his creation, and close our mouth and bow our knee.
“Behold, I am of small account; what shall I answer you?
I lay my hand on my mouth. (Job 40:4)
But who are you, O man, to answer back to God?
(Romans 9:20 )
No comments:
Post a Comment